|

Why Budgeting Sucks (and What to Do Instead)

ByRobert Goudie Updated on Budgeting, Education

Why Traditional Budgeting Fails

We’ve all been told that the key to managing money is to create a budget and stick to it. Track every dollar, set spending limits, and make sure you don’t overspend in any category. It sounds good in theory!

But let’s be real—most people fail at budgeting. Not because they don’t care about their money, but because strict budgeting is rigid, time-consuming, and difficult to maintain long-term.

You might start strong, logging every coffee and grocery run, but life gets busy. Unexpected expenses pop up. One month, you go over in groceries but under in entertainment—does that mean you failed? For couples, it can create friction, with one person treating the budget as law and the other feeling like they’re constantly being policed.

Traditional budgeting focuses too much on small expenses and not enough on the big financial moves that actually build wealth.

That’s why I don’t believe in tracking every dollar. Instead, I use a big-picture approach that prioritises the financial decisions that truly matter—while allowing you to spend guilt-free on everything else.

The “No-Budget” Approach: Focus on Big Wins

Instead of micromanaging your spending, I focus on these three key areas:

Home Loan Payoff – Instead of stretching out a 30-year mortgage, automate extra repayments to shave years off your loan. The interest savings alone can far outweigh small budgeting tweaks.

Superannuation & Investments – Are you investing enough for retirement? Super is a great vehicle for tax benefits, but you should also consider investments outside super for financial freedom before retirement age.

Emergency & Future Savings – Having accessible cash reserves means less reliance on credit cards and loans when unexpected costs arise.

Once you’ve allocated funds to these priorities, the rest is yours to spend however you like—guilt-free.

This removes the stress of tracking every little expense while ensuring that your financial future is still being taken care of.

Why This Approach Works Better

Less Stress, More Freedom – No more spreadsheets, logging expenses, or feeling guilty for small indulgences. If your financial priorities are funded first, there’s no need to sweat the small stuff.

Automates Financial Success – Instead of relying on self-discipline, automate your mortgage overpayments, super contributions, and investments. When it’s set up to happen automatically, you don’t have to think about it.

Focuses on What Actually Matters – Cutting back on small expenses won’t make you rich, but owning your home sooner, investing regularly, and securing your future will.

Works for All Income Levels – Whether you earn $60K or $250K a year, prioritising big financial moves makes more impact than cutting out lattes.

How to Implement This “No-Budget” Plan

Identify Your Big Priorities – What financial goals will actually change your life? Think: paying off debt, funding retirement, or building investments.

Crunch the Numbers – Work out how much extra you could allocate each month toward these goals. Even small adjustments (e.g., an extra $200 toward your mortgage) can make a big difference over time.

Automate It – Set up automatic transfers to ensure your priorities happen first. This removes temptation and decision fatigue.

Spend the Rest Freely – Once your major financial moves are covered, whatever’s left is yours to enjoy. No more tracking every coffee or meal out.

Review Every 6-12 Months – Instead of daily or weekly budgeting, do a bigger-picture check-in a couple of times a year to adjust as needed.

Final Thoughts: A Smarter Way to Manage Money

Traditional budgeting tries to control every little expense, but it’s not sustainable for most people. The better approach? Focus on automating big financial wins first, then spend the rest without guilt.

By prioritising home loan repayments, investing for the future, and having a financial safety net, you’re securing long-term wealth and financial freedom—without stressing over whether you spent too much on dinner last week.

Forget budgeting. Focus on the big wins, automate your plan, and let your money work for you—without the hassle.



The information provided in this article is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial advice.  

Return to Rob’s Page Browse More Posts From Rob

Similar Posts

Super success for women

Super success for women

Updated on Retirement, Superannuation

While women earn less and spend less time in the workforce than men, sharply reducing their super contributions throughout their working lives, there are some simple steps women can take to boost their retirement savings. The Simple Facts This inequality is simply due to women earning and working less. Women in full-time work earn on average 18 per cent less than men, while almost half of all women in the workforce work part-time with an estimated 220,000 women missing out on any super contributions each year simply because they earn less than $450 a month – the lower threshold for super guarantee contributions. Women also miss out on super contributions because they are often absent from the workforce for extended periods while on maternity leave or looking after loved ones, be they children or other family relatives. When they do return to the workforce, it is frequently in casual positions or working for themselves, where the need to make super contributions is so often overlooked. Check your super fund fees and charges The solution lies with women taking control of their super and choosing the best possible super fund, which typically means low fees and good, low-risk investment options. Regularly check what, if any, personal insurance premiums are paid from your precious super savings. While insurance is essential while you are raising a family, as you get older, you might find your need for insurance diminishes. You may be able to reduce your coverage and with it the cost of premiums from your super. (Remember to always check with your adviser before cancelling any insurances.) Make sure you take the time to consolidate your super accounts into one low cost super fund. Visit the Australian Tax Office website to consolidate your super or ask your adviser to do this for you. Wherever possible, ensure you continue to make contributions throughout your working life, starting as early as possible and not neglecting your superannuation during periods when you are out of the workforce, working on a part-time basis or self-employed. Maximise Your Contributions Make sure you speak to your adviser to maximise your contributions, and in doing so, minimise your tax bill at the end of the financial year. If you expect your income to be less than $52,000 in a financial year, make sure you take advantage of the Federal Government’s co-contribution scheme. By putting just $20 a week of after-tax income into super, you will receive up to $500 from the Government directly into your super account as soon as you lodge your tax return. That’s a guaranteed 50 per cent return on your money and the best investment you will ever make. If you are earning less than $37,000 a year, you should receive the Federal Government’s low-income superannuation tax offset of $500. Both payments happen automatically, meaning you don’t have to apply or complete additional paperwork to receive them. Still, you should check your superannuation account to make sure these payments are there. If you need more advice about your super, talk to us today.   The information provided in this article is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial advice.

6 steps to a sustainable Christmas

6 steps to a sustainable Christmas

Budgeting

Just as the Grinch stole Christmas, excess spending can rob us all of yuletide happiness. Seasonal credit card splurges can create ballooning long term debt, while unnecessary consumption inevitably leads to a blow-out in rubbish bin waste. The Commonwealth Bank of Australia estimates $11 billion is spent on presents each year, including some 20 million unwanted gifts. At the same time, seasonal celebrations boost landfill rubbish by a massive 30 per cent. So, if you want to max out the ho, ho, ho in Christmas this year, think of applying more whoa, whoa, whoa to your spending and consumption ideas. Here are six simple tips Ebenezer Scrooge would be proud of: Ninety per cent of Australians claim to recycle something, sometimes. What better way to do this than to shop for presents in one of Australia’s 2,500 opportunity shops? Forget the old days of chipped crockery and stained used clothing. Op shops are full of trendy, mint condition items and are the perfect place to find something slightly offbeat or unusual for your loved one. Save on postage and reduce needless paper usage by sending clever and original e-Christmas cards. Head online to create your seasonal messages to email to friends and family. Many websites provide free cards, while others offer designer animated versions. Instead of giving a physical gift, give an experience such as tickets to a concert or a voucher to use at a favourite restaurant. Better still, why not gift something special of yourself by offering to cook a meal or provide free babysitting for a family member. Giving an experience rather than a physical gift also means you don’t need to waste precious paper by wrapping the present or spend money on postage getting it to that special someone. If you do give a physical present, think of some clever ways to wrap it, so you’re not adding to the 150,000 km of wrapping paper Australians needlessly use each year – that’s enough paper to circle the equator 4 times. Wrap your gift in a re-usable patterned tea towel or scarf, or better still, invest in some brightly patterned boxes to hold your present that can be recycled from one Christmas to the next. Stop for a moment and look around your home to see what you can re-use and turn into a gift. A great place to start is the garden. Many plants can be easily divided and, in doing so, will create new plants you can pot up in a re-usable pot to give away. Take time to plan your meals this season and, wherever possible, cut down on buying heavily packaged or processed foods. Instead, buy fresh foods that can be eaten without much cooking, re-used as leftovers, or frozen for later consumption. It’s estimated that ninety per cent of Australians discard some 25 per cent of all the food they buy during December – that’s food that has been needlessly produced only to end up in Australia’s landfills. What really matters is remembering how blessed we are to be enjoying the festive season in whatever way we can and being with the people we care about most.   The information provided in this article is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial advice.

It’s time to get focused on super in your 40s

It’s time to get focused on super in your 40s

Updated on Budgeting, Education, Finance, Investing, Retirement, Superannuation

Typically your forties is a time of established careers, teenage kids and a mortgage that is no longer daunting. There are still plenty of demands on the budget, but by this age there’s a good chance there’s some spare cash that can be put to good use. A beneficial sacrificeAt this age, a popular strategy for boosting retirement savings is ‘salary sacrifice’ in which you take a cut in take-home pay in exchange for additional pre-tax contributions to your super. If you are self-employed, you can increase your tax-deductible contributions, within the concessional limit, to gain the same benefit. Salary sacrificing provides a double benefit. Not only are you adding more money to your retirement balance, these contributions and their earnings are taxed at only 15%. If you earn between $90,001 and $180,000 per year that money would otherwise be taxed at 39%. Sacrifice $1,000 per month over the course of a year and you’ll be $2,880 better off just from the tax benefits alone. It’s important to remember that if combined salary sacrifice and superannuation guarantee contributions exceed $25,000 in a given year the amount above this limit will be added to your assessable income and taxed at your marginal tax rate. What about the mortgage?Paying the mortgage down quickly has long been a sound wealth-building strategy for many. Current low interest rates and the tax benefits of salary sacrifice, combined with a good long-term investment return, means that putting your money into super produces the better outcome in most cases. One caveat – if you think you might need to access that money before retiring don’t put it into super. Pay down the mortgage and redraw should you need to. Let the government contributeLow-income earners can pick up an easy, government-sponsored, 50% return on their investment just by making an after-tax contribution to their super fund. If you can contribute $1,000 of your own money to super, you could receive up to $500 as a co-contribution. Another strategy that may help some couples is contribution splitting. This is where a portion of one partner’s superannuation contributions are rolled over to the partner on a lower income. Your financial adviser will be able to help you decide if this strategy would benefit you. Protect what you can’t afford to loseWith debts and dependants, adequate life insurance cover is crucial. Holding cover through superannuation may provide benefits such as lower premiums, a tax deduction to the super fund and reduced strain on cash flow. Make sure the sum insured is sufficient for your needs as default cover amounts are usually well short of what’s required. Seek professional adviceThe forties is an important decade for wealth creation with many things to consider, so talk to us and we’ll help you make sure the next 20 years are the best for your super.   This is general information only

Why financial advice may be your best investment

Why financial advice may be your best investment

Updated on Education, Investing

It is commonly assumed that seeking financial advice is for the wealthy, and it only helps the rich become richer, yet financial advice can prove useful to anyone who wishes to better their financial future. Financial advice is like getting a health check-up for your financial situation. Your financial adviser is like your personal trainer, assisting you in achieving your best possible financial health. Seeking professional financial advice provides you with a clear path to achieve your financial goals, and that is an investment worth making. Why invest in financial advice? Financial advice isn’t only about investing your money in the share market. Want to save to buy your first home? Want to protect your children in case of your death? Want to enjoy a comfortable retirement? Don’t understand what to do with your super or how to invest in the share market? Think of a financial adviser as a one-stop shop for the majority of your financial issues in life. Come to think of it, be it your parents telling you to save money from your first job or an Instagram ‘finfluencer’ explaining the benefits of compound interest while dancing to a trendy song, these are all informal pieces of financial advice you receive throughout your lifetime. However, a professional adviser can legally provide holistic advice by reviewing your entire financial situation and your risk-taking capacity to recommend an appropriate investment portfolio. Also, an adviser’s investment recommendations are based on research which can give you comfort over your decisions rather than constantly worrying about the investment you made based on your work colleague’s stock ‘tip’. Is financial advice cost effective? The financial advice industry has undergone a monumental transformation following the Financial Services Royal Commission of 2017-2019. As a result, new education and compliance requirements have been legislated to further protect the client’s best interests. This has led to a drop in the number of financial advisers Australia-wide – from approximately 28,000 in 2018 to just 19,000 in 2021. The silver lining here is that while there are fewer advisers to choose from, the quality of advice is deemed to improve exponentially. As per Russell Investments “Value of an Adviser” report, advisers added a value of approximately 5.2 per cent to their client’s portfolios in the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic. Still, the true value of financial advice is much more than comparing the fees you pay against the performance of your investments, or the tax saved on your income. A financial adviser can be a sounding board for your financial ideas, a resource to answer the simplest or most complex of queries, provide research-backed recommendations, and guide you over the long term based on their experience. Ready to make the investment? Your day to day job may not allow you to focus on the financial aspect of your life. In contrast, your financial adviser’s primary daily responsibility is to help you handle your finances efficiently. So, are you ready for your financial check-up? Take the first step and book an appointment with us today.   The information provided in this article is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial advice.

Is FORO ruining your retirement?

Is FORO ruining your retirement?

Updated on Education, Finance, Retirement

FORO – the fear of running out. I’d never heard the expression until I met Mark and Susan. Of course I’d heard of FOMO, the fear of missing out, but never FORO. As the newly-retired couple sat across from me, explaining how they were so afraid of running out of savings that they were not enjoying the retirement they’d worked so diligently for, I grasped the meaning of FORO immediately. They rarely went out for dinner, bought anything new or – heaven forbid – took a holiday. After a lifetime of saving hard, paying off a mortgage and raising a family, Mark and Susan were naturally frugal, but FORO had left them feeling vulnerable and afraid of the future. After two decades as a financial planner, I’d come across this situation before, although, it is unfortunately becoming more common. Mark and Susan had never sought financial advice before and weren’t sure what I could do to help, but came to see me because they didn’t know where else to turn. When I assured them that there was plenty I could do to help, they visibly relaxed. I explained that the key to overcoming FORO was having a well-structured financial plan. After I outlined my 5-step strategy, they were eager to proceed. The steps we took were as follows: 1. Conduct a financial assessment By thoroughly assessing their current financial position (superannuation, savings, investment and social security entitlement), I formulated a picture of where they were at, and their future cash flow projections.  2. Establish a sensible strategy Working together, we identified essential living expenses and discretionary expenses, then allocated funding that balanced financial security with lifestyle goals. Next, we determined a retirement investment portfolio with a sensible withdrawal rate to support their retirement plans. 3. Create an emergency buffer In my experience, the what if factor is a major concern for retirees. What if…I become ill? What if…the fridge breaks down? What if…the car dies? These questions, and more, play on peoples’ minds to the point where they fall back into a FORO mind set. To ease their anxiety, I recommended they include a contingency fund in their portfolio to ensure that unplanned expenses were covered. That way, if something unexpected pops up, their retirement lifestyle strategy remains on track. 4. Enjoy the early years FORO had been holding Mark and Susan back for too long. I explained that hobbies, travel and social activities are crucial to mental well-being. So once we had established a responsible financial plan, I showed them how they could afford to spend, sensibly, and enjoy themselves. I especially encouraged them to make the most of their early retirement years, while they were fit and energetic. 5. Schedule regular reviews The final step in the process was my ongoing commitment to Mark and Susan. Retirement planning is not a set-and-forget strategy; it’s a journey through every stage of life – physical retirement being one of those stages. By regularly reviewing their financial position, I helped Mark and Susan monitor their spending and investment performance, and made portfolio adjustments that kept them in control of their retirement plan. Last week I bumped into the couple on the street. They were glowing with excitement and told me they’d just booked a Pacific cruise. Of course, I was thrilled for them – it was a big tick off the bucket list! But when Susan said they’d turned FORO into FOMO and were living their best lives, well, I’ll just say it was one of those moments when I absolutely love my job! The information provided in this article is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial advice.  

Who gets your super?

Who gets your super?

Updated on Superannuation

Who decides what happens to your superannuation savings when you die? You may think that you do, but that isn’t always the case. The ultimate decision may be made by someone you don’t even know – the trustee of your superannuation fund. Let’s look at how you can have greater control. Binding death benefit nominations The most certain way to direct payment of your superannuation death benefit is by making a binding death benefit nomination. The nominated beneficiaries must be ’dependants’ – a spouse, de facto spouse, child or financial dependant – or a legal personal representative (i.e. the executor or administrator of a deceased estate.) If the nomination has been properly signed and witnessed, and is still current at the date of death, then the trustees of the superannuation fund must pay the death benefit to the nominated beneficiaries. Unlike Wills, valid binding superannuation nominations are unlikely to be overturned by a court, so they provide great certainty. It is up to the trustees of each superannuation fund to decide whether or not to allow binding nominations, so they aren’t available to everyone. Although some funds offer non-lapsing binding death benefit nominations, most are only valid for three years, so it’s important to check yours and ensure it remains up-to-date. Trustee’s discretion The trustee is under a legal obligation to pay a death benefit to the member’s dependants, and in most cases, benefits will be paid in a way that is consistent with the wishes of the deceased member. However, it is possible the trustee may recognise a wider range of dependants than the member would have liked – including a separated spouse. In some cases, the member’s preferred beneficiary may not meet the legal definition of a dependant. This may apply to parents. In the absence of any dependants and a legal personal representative, the trustee may exercise their discretion, and pay the benefit to a non-dependant. While dependants receive lump-sum death benefits tax free, the rate of tax payable by non-dependants can vary from nil to 30% depending on the components of the superannuation payment. Superannuation pensions The situation is a little different if the member has already retired and is drawing a superannuation pension. With pensions, it is common to nominate a surviving spouse as a reversionary beneficiary. This means the pension payments will continue to be paid to the nominee, either until their death, or until the funds run out. If the reversionary beneficiary dies, any remaining balance is then paid out as a lump sum death benefit according to the type of nomination they have made. Good advice required Increasing levels of wealth being held via superannuation and the nomination of beneficiaries should be made in the context of a comprehensive estate plan. This includes taking into account the way superannuation death benefits are taxed when paid to different types of beneficiaries. We can help you make the right decision.   The information provided in this article is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial advice.